Lucy Gutsell was born circa 1820 in Sydney, New South Wales, Australia to John Gutsell (c1784-1853) and Frances Tomsett (c1785-1853) and died before 1825 Sydney, New South Wales, Australia of unspecified causes.
The only record of Lucy is found in the 1822 Muster of the Colony of New South Wales when she is recorded with her mother and elder sisters at the age of 2 years. She is not with her mother and sisters in the 1825 census when she would, if she had still been living, have been 5 years old.