Rev. Nathaniel Butler was born 14 June 1761 in Cumberland, Providence County, Rhode Island, United States to Benjamin Butler (1727-1800) and Susanna Whiting (1734-1757) and died 29 September 1829 Cumberland, Providence County, Rhode Island, United States of unspecified causes. He married Sarah Herrick (1764-c1823) 12 June 1783 in Cumberland, Providence County, Rhode Island, United States.
Children
| Name | Birth | Death | Joined with |
| Samuel Herrick Butler (1785-1851) | 12 March 1785 Bennington, Bennington County, Vermont, United States | 13 December 1851 Columbus, Fairfield County, Ohio, United States | Judith Livingston (1785-1858) |
Siblings