Familypedia
Advertisement


Remove Family line of Alpaida (794-)[]

I moved Alpaida (794-) and her mother to the 10th spouse slot for Charlemagne (747-814) with the recommendation that we delete her and all of her descendants. Not one of these is listed in Wikipedia / GENI or any other known source. Plus there is at least 10 generations that appear to be totally made up and fictitious. I am voting for this family line to be removed entirely.

In fact I cannot find any listing for any of the Counts of Bassigny (See Category) (eg Gosselin I de Bassigny (c836-c861) or any of his ancestors.) For something as extremely important as Project Charlemagne - I think we need to be accurate with good documentation and not just throwing names up here. MainTour (talk) 01:44, November 25, 2018 (UTC)

There is some documentation for this family in French Wikipedia : Donat Ier de Melun - which actually seems to also disprove this link to Charlemagne. MainTour (talk) 03:06, November 25, 2018 (UTC)

  • Carolingian History - Medlands Project - See Entry #15 - possible daughter [ADALTRUD] by unnamed mistress - no named descendants. MainTour (talk) 16:04, November 25, 2018 (UTC)


Good work! I agree in principle. Maybe rtol can offer relevant documentation. --- Robin Patterson (Talk) 04:17, November 26, 2018 (UTC)
Advertisement